I don’t think I have ever dealt with a political issue on this blog. In another life I do wedding photography and so I have been thinking about this one for a long time. Here is my two cents:
It is not that the Indiana Law is (RFRA) is pro-gay or anti-gay. It is that it is too vague and impossible for normal people to understand. And this is the real kicker: it fundamentally does not deal with the issue that needs to be clarified.
Is it OK for a wedding photographer to refuse to shoot a gay wedding ceremony? Can he or she be sued for refusing to do so?
Here is what I suggest.
- If you are open for business, you are open for business for everyone. If you serve the public, you serve gays, whites, black, old, young, Christians, atheists and Muslims. If you do photography, you shoot gay couples.
- There should be a narrow exception. There should be a conscientious objector clause. There should be a narrow exception to the above rule. You should not be required to participate in a gay wedding ceremony if you believe that the marrying of homosexuals is wrong. You should be able to register as a conscientious objector of gay marriage. This would exempt a photographer from being compelled to shoot gay weddings. It would exempt anyone in the wedding-support business from being compelled to service a Gay Wedding. This would include, but not be limited to the following service providers: photographers, wedding planners, caterers, D.J., etc. The status of conscientious objector could be publically displayed on websites and in a place of business.
Trying to put myself in the position of a position of a gay person, I think this is what I would want. I would not want someone who felt gay marriage was morally wrong to shoot my wedding. I would want to be able to find out this information without having to ask.
The intent of these laws has always been to protect minority groups. We need to be clear about who the minority is in this case. It is not those who support Gay Rights. They are clearly in the majority. The minority that needs to be protected are those who believe in the traditional Christian view of marriage. They should have the right to not be compelled to participate in something they believe to wrong.
A call to civility. It is my sincere hope that we can enter into this important debate with civility, respect and love.

























Do you photograph only weddings? If not, then what about other photography requests? How about if someone wants to do a nude photo shoot in the privacy of their home? What about a lady who desires something risqué–not nude, but enough that you would find it, “dirty?” If two teen transvestite boys want prom pictures, including some of them making out, would you take those shots? I am not arguing with you–just trying to process your proposal. I just think you should have the liberty to refuse to photograph anyone or anything based on a religious and moral objection–and the state would have to offer a compelling argument that your refusal was for other reasons (racial, etc.) and that it worked a hardship on those bringing the lawsuit (such as being unable to buy a cake or purchase photos elsewhere at a comparable price and quality). I do not believe that most of the current attacks on businesses have anything to do with civil rights–though perhaps some do–rather it is an orchestrated effort to steamroll all opposition to deviancy. Thanks for the opportunity to comment!
Good question. I have never been asked to do nude photos, but would definitely turn it down and hope for the best legally
I agree with your article about the law–the government should not force people to participate in services that violate their conscience.